Jump to content
North Side Baseball

AL MVP  

47 members have voted

  1. 1. AL MVP

    • Trout
      39
    • Cabrera
      8


Posted

Lots of fascinating chatter on this lately.

 

I personally think it's Trout and it's not even all that close in my mind. Cabrera is the better hitter, but not so much more to outweigh Trouts amazing defense and baserunning.

 

The Triple Crown is special, but now that we have a better understanding of statistics, it doesn't carry nearly the weight it use to.

Recommended Posts

Posted
Ooops, I guess I should have actually read the question before voting for Miggy. I figured the question was who WILL win the AL MVP, not who SHOULD. I think Cabrera will win it but Trout certainly should.
Posted
Seeing a guy win a Triple Crown was cool, since I've never been alive for one. But Trout should be MVP. Doubt the voters agree though.
Posted
Between Detroit making the playoffs and LA not making them and Cabrera winning the Triple Crown, there's no way Cabrera won't win the MVP.
Posted
I think it should be Trout, but it's hard to hate on the idea of a Triple Crown winner who made the playoffs winning it, either. (Yes, I know the Angels won more games.)
Posted
Well if it was up to us it would be a landslide. I think it should go to Trout but as others have said, I can't see any way it doesn't go to Miggy. It's not like he's undeserving though.

 

He's undeserving when compared to the awesomeness that is Mike Trout.

Posted
I love the Cabrera led his team to the playoffs argument, even though the Angels won more games in a way better division.

 

Exactly. As a fun fact, the AL west was 101-73 against the Central.

Posted

here's a scout that BP asked:

 

“Miguel Cabrera is the MVP. Mike Trout is a better baseball player, but so is Robinson Cano, Matt Kemp, and a handful of others. None were more valuable to their club, over the course of the season, than Cabrera. He was consistently great for 6 months, 161 games. He had a better 2nd half and, more importantly when talking about value, he was at his best during the pennant race. The Triple Crown was last achieved 45 years ago. No matter what you think of AVG, HR, and RBI, the feat is amazing. There's value in all 3 categories. The most I believe is in the ability to drive in runs. RBI aren't about luck. It's bat control and sacrificing personal stats like AVG to do whatever is needed to get the run in. Cabrera was even better in these situations. Cabrera was also supposed to be a killer at 3B. He ended the season with only 13 errors and somehow had a range factor higher than Adrian Beltre. He hardly cost the Tigers the way everyone assumes. Trout was very good in CF, but did move to LF late in games 35 times for Peter Bourjos. Either Bourjos can't play LF or he's that much better than Trout in CF.”
Posted
i love that he argues that RBIs are about sacrificing "personal stats like AVG to do whatever is needed to get the run in" when the guy he's talking about also had the highest batting average in the league. imagine how awesome his batting average would be if he weren't sacrificing all those at bats to knock in runs!!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...